West Field students have been acting out because of the new phone ban policy enforced by the state. Students feel that the policy is too strict and restrictive, while teachers believe that it enhances their education.
Students at West Field have shared that they are often worried about safety without their phones being able to be in access at any time. West Field sophomore, Lena Gillaspy speaks on behalf of this. She said “Not having access to your phone is unsafe because I am less able to contact my parents during emergency situations.” While many students interviewed agree with this statement, Melissa Powell, an administrator, stated that the school has access to many phones that students can use to contact their parents when in need.
While interviewing Coach Eric Jones, he stated that “Having a ban is one thing and enforcing and following it is another thing, but when it is followed, it is a great thing.” Teachers at West Field are having a hard time having students follow the policy, so they are not fully set on seeing far more improvements so far. Powell also shared, “I wish teachers were more set on taking kids’ phones if they see them as part of the policy.” Students tend to not accept the policy and go against it, therefore, it can be hard for teachers to enforce it that way.
Sophomore Cole Jorgenson stated, “My phone is like a mental health break for me, and it gives me a distraction when needed.” With the new policy, students aren’t allowed to use their phones at all, and sometimes they need that little break to decrease anxiety. Jorgenson also said, “Sometimes I need an escape from reality to get back to being focused.”
On the other hand, some students have said they do enjoy it and have seen an increase in their education because of it. Sophomore Summer Sved shared, “I miss not having my phone out at all times, but it means I actually can focus on my work, so I am okay with it.” The change of phone usage may be hard, but it can be a benefit for some students who have more trouble paying attention when distractions are present. Powell also shared interesting news that even some of the students at West Field have shared that the ban makes them focused, and they have gotten better grades because of it.
The phone ban policy has already impacted many students and faculty members’ lives so much in such a short period. Are students’ education being affected? Is this affecting/helping with bullying at West Field? In the future, West Field students overall hope to see a change in the policy or their education. “Change is the result of all true learning,” Leo Buscagila.